Eugene Cho has a nice commentary on Glenn Beck’s recent remarks about the communist churches in America.
I usually don’t listen to Glenn Beck becuase he gets my blood boiling. Today, I happened to catch a few minutes of Glenn Beck and finally my pressure cooker went off and I need to respond. He was speaking about his remarks concerning the social justice movement in church and he challenged his listeners to find a passage that Jesus supports the redistribution of wealth. Of course, there isn’t any clear cut passage.
Here is the lack of logic in his argument. Can you find a passage where Jesus is against abortion? How about slavery? Can you find a passage where Jesus supports capitalism? Or democracy? Of course you can’t. I could argue, using Glenn Beck’s logic, that God loves chickens more than turkeys because Jesus never endorses turkeys in the gospels. There are many topics that the gospel writers did not write about or that Jesus never spoke about. But we make religious claims about those issues based upon the intent of Jesus’ words or by comparing Scripture to Scripture.
The quick point is that Jesus never explicitly condemns or endorses the redistribution of wealth. But clear arguments can be made that the redistribution of wealth could be supported Biblically and perhaps by Jesus. The Old Testament points to the more equitable distribution of wealth by calling the people to care for the widows and orphans. God when He sent manna sent it in such a way that the ones who had much didn’t have too much. Those who gathered little didn’t not have too little. There was some equity, though not uniformity, in the distribution of food.
Paul elaborates on this when he says that the church has fulfilled this manna call (2 Corinthians 8:13-15). The early church lived in a community that redistributed its wealth (Acts 2:44). Glenn would probably go nuts in the first century church.
Lastly, Jesus taught us to pray: Your will be done on earth as it is in heaven. Is there poverty in heaven? Are there large discrepancies in the wealth of people in heaven? Since there probably are not large discrepancies in heaven, we should work to do the same on earth. Jesus said that some of the last will be first and the first will be last. Does that apply to economics? How about those sheep who looked after “the least of these”? I think a strong case can be made that Jesus had some intent of social justice.
Here are a couple sites talking about Glenn Beck’s latest tyrade:
Wantagh posts their response on their sign
AlterNet talks about the nazi Jesus








